
Warning: Minor spoilers ahead.
I love Sci-Fi. The Sci-Fi I watched as a kid is the reason I do what I do today.
But, more-over, I love great Sci-Fi. And some of the best Sci-Fi we’ve ever seen has come from the Star Trek universe (be it The Original Series, The Animated Series, The Next Generation, etc.).
Some of the greatest writers of our time have worked on these shows. D.C. Fontana, Harlan Ellison, Larry Niven and David Gerrold immediately spring to mind.
So when we found out J. J. Abrams was going to be making a movie that took place in The Original Series timeframe (and with the original characters)… I was… concerned.
Turns out — those concerns were justified.
I saw the new movie the first moment I could. And you can listen to my review of it in the latest episode of Casta Blasta (hint: There’s four guys on CastaBlasta. I’m the one who didn’t love it so much.)
I’m not going to go into a full on review here. Whether or not I like this movie shouldn’t matter to you. If you like Star Trek, you really should see this film.
What I would like to talk about is what a colossal mistake this film was to make. (We’re talking a Dr. Richard Daystrom level of mistake here.)
“But Bryan! The movie did great openning weekend! And so many people are enjoying it and being exposed to Star Trek for the first time! How can that be bad?”
That is a great question. And I’ll give you the quickest answer I possibly can.
JJ’s Star Trek reboots the franchise. But that’s not the real problem.
The problem is that it reboots the franchise… while making it a direct continuation of the timeline from the original Star Trek.
What this means is that it’s not a completely different “thing”. If you or I sit down and watch JJ’s Star Trek we cannot simply consider it on its own merits. Because it is directly tied, by the events in the film, to the original Star Trek Univers (Pre-JJ).
Also this means that, since JJ’s Star Trek is in the same “universe” and has a direct timeline connection to the pre-JJ Trek (as opposed to a “pure reboot with no connection”), several problems immediately crop up.
- All those great moments in Star Trek? Not there any more. Tribbles? Gone. City on the Edge of Forever? Not there. Wrath of Khan? Nope. Not happening. So now, when we sit down to watch those wonderful shows — those epic moments in Sci-Fi history — we know that the new Star Trek movie has erased them from that universe.
- What if there is a chance of seeing a new series or movie (or game) based on the many existing Star Trek series? While those chances may have been slim before… they’re a lot lower now.
- It was “rebooted” as a film, not a television series. Which means we aren’t likely to ever get those defining moments that made Trek what it is (seriously… how likely is it they’ll make a Tribbles movie?).
- Because it was an expensive movie. And because any sequels are likely to go up in price (there are some great actors in this movie… they aren’t likely to get cheaper). How likely do you think it is we’ll get a constant stream of new Trek movies in this universe? Not likely. Maybe one? Two? Then it’s done.
- JJ’s Trek is designed to also appeal to the Gilmore Girls / Greys Anatomy fans. Spock making out with Uhura? Really?
The result?
The original Star Trek (Pre-JJ Abrams) has been rendered inert and impossible (or at least extremely unlikely) to expand upon in TV or film form.
And the odds of getting a large quantity (and quality) of movies and TV shows from this “new” timeline of Trek, well, that looks pretty slim even with this movie doing well at the box office.
And, even if we do get that, good odds it’ll be more akin to the super, over the top drama that has been the hallmark of some recent Sci Fi (ala Lost and the final two seasons of the new Battlestar Galactica). ie. “Not Star Trek”.
So, what’s this all mean? It’s definitely not good, I’ll tell you that.
Can it be fixed? Sure. This is Sci-Fi. You can fix anything.
Maybe if they brought in some of the “old guard” of great Sci Fi writers that have contributed so much to the Trek universe (see the writers above for a good starting point) to fix it…
But. In the mean time. I think it’s safe to say this new Star Trek movie did about as much to kill off Star Trek as you possibly could do.